Roast Meridian
The coffee shelf

Measurement

Strength and extraction describe different things

Calling coffee strong can hide two different questions: how concentrated is the drink, and how much material was extracted from the grounds? Research writing associated with Montréal scientist Jonathan Gagné and UC Davis provides a clearer vocabulary for comparing brews.

Source review: 5 October 2026

Inside this story
01

A Montréal connection to measurement

Espace pour la vie’s account of scientific fieldwork points readers towards Jonathan Gagné’s coffee investigations alongside his work in astrophysics. His Coffee ad Astra writing applies quantitative questions to an ingredient that often attracts descriptions based entirely on taste.

That connection is useful because the central issue is a method of thinking: decide what is being measured before comparing results. Brewing can be examined through mass and concentration without assuming that the same numerical result will satisfy every drinker.

Sources: Ville de Montréal, Espace pour la vie — Researchers’ fieldwork: a journey to major telescopes (French source).

02

Concentration concerns the finished beverage

Gagné describes beverage concentration in terms of dissolved coffee material relative to the mass of the drink. A refractometer provides a measurement commonly expressed as total dissolved solids, or TDS. This describes what is in the beverage that reaches the cup.

The water originally poured into a brewer is not identical to the beverage collected. Some remains in the wet grounds. Keeping those quantities separate is essential when interpreting measurements, particularly when comparing records made with different brewing methods.

Sources: Jonathan Gagné, Coffee ad Astra — Measuring and Reporting Extraction Yield.

03

Yield concerns the starting grounds

Extraction yield relates dissolved material to the original dry coffee dose. It answers a different question from concentration: what fraction of the starting grounds has contributed dissolved material? A clear record distinguishes the dose, the beverage mass and the concentration measurement.

As a conceptual comparison, adding water to an already separated beverage reduces its concentration while leaving the amount previously extracted from the grounds unchanged. This simple distinction explains why a drink can be diluted without reversing the extraction that produced it.

Sources: Jonathan Gagné, Coffee ad Astra — Measuring and Reporting Extraction Yield.

04

Numbers help describe a tasting experiment

The UC Davis Coffee Center summarizes studies that varied brew strength and extraction yield and examined the resulting sensory responses. Its publications also report differences in consumer preferences, showing why a single prescribed numerical target cannot stand in for everyone’s experience.

The practical value of a measurement is a more precise comparison. Record what changed and what remained fixed, then describe the taste separately. This keeps a brewing note useful while avoiding the assumption that a concentration reading, by itself, is a complete score for quality.

Sources: UC Davis Coffee Center — Publications.

Primary sources

  1. Measuring and Reporting Extraction YieldJonathan Gagné, Coffee ad Astra
  2. PublicationsUC Davis Coffee Center
  3. Researchers’ fieldwork: a journey to major telescopes (French source)Ville de Montréal, Espace pour la vie